Top 10 Real Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark

If you love gathering around a campfire or huddling under blankets with friends, swapping tales that send shivers down your spine, this list is for you. These 10 true scary stories, rooted in real paranormal events and personal experiences, are perfect for telling in the dark. They’re not just creepy, they’re real accounts that’ll make your group glance into the shadows and wonder what’s out there. Written in simple, modern English, these stories are designed to grip everyone listening, no matter their age. So, dim the lights, grab a flashlight, and let’s dive into these chilling tales that prove the supernatural can be all too real.

Click this idea to save it later.

1. The Phantom of the Stanley Hotel

In Estes Park, Colorado, the Stanley Hotel, built in 1909, is famous for inspiring Stephen King’s The Shining. Guests and staff report seeing a man in a suit, believed to be F.O. Stanley, wandering the halls. One spooky detail: the piano in the ballroom plays itself at night. A 2016 guest shared on a travel blog hearing keys tinkling with no one there. Another chilling account involves Room 217, where a maid died in an explosion. Visitors feel cold touches and see her figure folding clothes. Ghost tours, costing about 25 dollars per person per the hotel’s website, draw crowds. This tale, with its eerie music and ghostly hospitality, is perfect for a dark night’s scare.

2. The Hitchhiker of Route 44

Along Route 44 in Massachusetts, drivers have reported a creepy encounter since the 1960s. A man with red hair and a beard, dressed in flannel, flags down cars, only to vanish from the back seat after being picked up. A 1990s driver told a local paper he chatted with the man about the weather before noticing he was gone. Some link the ghost to a fatal accident on the road decades ago. No tours exist, as it’s a public highway, but the story’s consistency makes it a chilling tale to share, especially when driving through the dark woods of New England.

3. The Crying Lady of Belmez

In 1971, in Belmez, Spain, Maria Pereira noticed a face appearing on her kitchen floor. It looked like a woman crying, and no amount of scrubbing removed it. New faces kept forming, even after the floor was replaced. Neighbors and investigators saw the faces change expressions. Paranormal experts, including German Hansel, studied the house, ruling out paint or tricks. Visitors reported hearing soft sobs at night. The house, now a private residence, isn’t open for tours, but the story, documented in Spanish newspapers, is perfect for a spooky night, making you wonder if faces could appear in your own home.

4. The Ghosts of the Lizzie Borden House

In Fall River, Massachusetts, the 1892 axe murders of Andrew and Abby Borden shocked the nation. Their daughter, Lizzie, was acquitted but suspected. Today, the house, now a bed-and-breakfast, is haunted. Guests report hearing footsteps, seeing a woman in Victorian dress, and feeling tugs on their clothes. A 2020 guest review on the house’s site described waking to a woman’s shadow at their bed. Overnight stays cost about 250 dollars per room per booking sites. With EVPs captured by paranormal teams saying “Get out,” this tale of unsolved murder and restless spirits is sure to creep out your listeners.

5. The Haunted Doll of Okiku

In Hokkaido, Japan, a doll named Okiku, owned by a young girl who died in 1918, is said to be possessed. The girl’s family noticed the doll’s hair growing longer, even after being trimmed. Visitors to the Mannenji Temple, where the doll is kept, report hearing it whisper at night. A 2015 tourist shared on a forum feeling uneasy near the doll’s glass case. The temple is open to visitors for free, but donations are welcomed. This story, with its eerie, growing hair, is perfect for a dark night, making everyone check their old toys twice.

6. The Shadow of the Ohio State Reformatory

The Ohio State Reformatory in Mansfield, operational until 1990, was a brutal prison where many inmates died. Now a museum, it’s known for shadowy figures in cells and screams echoing at night. A 2018 paranormal team recorded an EVP saying “I’m trapped.” A former guard, interviewed in 2019, described seeing a figure in the chapel vanish. Ghost tours, priced at about 35 dollars per person per the reformatory’s site, attract thousands. This tale of trapped spirits in a looming prison is ideal for storytelling, especially when shadows seem to move in the dark.

7. The White Lady of Balete Drive

In Quezon City, Philippines, Balete Drive is infamous for a ghostly woman in white who appears to drivers at night. Locals say she was killed in a car accident decades ago. Taxi drivers report picking her up, only for her to vanish, leaving a wet seat. A 2010 driver shared on a local radio show seeing her in his rearview mirror before she disappeared. No tours exist, as it’s a public road, but the story’s persistence in Filipino culture makes it a chilling tale to tell, especially when headlights flicker in the night.

8. The Haunting of the Ancient Ram Inn

The Ancient Ram Inn in Gloucestershire, England, built in 1145, is one of Britain’s most haunted buildings. Owner John Humphries, who lived there until 2018, reported beds shaking, voices whispering, and apparitions of a woman and children. Guests have fled after feeling strangled by unseen hands. A 2016 paranormal team captured an EVP saying “Leave now.” Ghost hunts, costing about 50 pounds per person per local operators, draw brave souls. With its ancient history and violent past, this story is perfect for a spooky night, making listeners wonder what lurks in old buildings.

9. The Bell Witch Cave

In Adams, Tennessee, the Bell Witch Cave is tied to the 1817 haunting of the Bell family. An entity, believed to be a vengeful spirit named Kate, tormented them with slaps, voices, and objects moving. John Bell’s mysterious death was blamed on the witch. Today, visitors to the cave report hearing laughter and feeling touches. A 2021 tourist shared on a travel site feeling dizzy and hearing whispers inside. Cave tours cost about 12 dollars per person per the site’s operators. This classic American ghost story, with its cave’s eerie vibes, is a must for dark-night storytelling.

10. The Ghosts of the Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum

The Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum in Weston, West Virginia, operational from 1864 to 1994, housed thousands of patients, many mistreated. Visitors report hearing screams, seeing figures in old hospital gowns, and feeling pushed in the halls. A 2019 investigation captured an EVP saying “Help us.” A former nurse, interviewed in 2015, described seeing a patient’s face in a window after their death. Ghost tours, priced at about 40 dollars per person per the asylum’s site, sell out fast. This tale of suffering spirits in a decaying asylum is sure to make your group huddle closer in the dark.

Why These Stories Are Perfect for the Dark

These 10 stories, drawn from real events across the globe, are tailor-made for telling in the dark. Their power lies in their truth—witnessed by ordinary people, documented by investigators, and backed by history. From the growing hair of Okiku’s doll to the vanishing hitchhiker on Route 44, each tale taps into our fear of the unknown. They’re short enough to share in one sitting but vivid enough to linger in your mind.

If you want to visit these spooky spots, places like the Stanley Hotel, Lizzie Borden House, and Trans-Allegheny Asylum offer tours (check their websites for current rates). But be careful—these stories might make you jump at every creak. Got a creepy tale of your own? Share it in the comments, and let’s keep the scares going. For now, maybe don’t look too closely into the darkness—you never know what’s looking back.